DangerWienie and FetaGirl
Hey, remember those baby-covered pre-natal handouts that I got from my OB/GYN's office? They're really dumb. They're right up there with stupid infertility books, except that instead of advising everyone to just relaaaaaaaax, they demand that everyone freak out.
I especially take issue with the section on Listeria. Everyone seems more than happy to warn you about the dire hazards of Listeriosis (and judging from the questions fielded on pregnancy forums, there are some seriously freaked out women out there), but very few handouts/websites seem willing to put those risks in perspective. No, they'd rather scare the shit out of everybody, because stressing out a pregnant woman is always a good idea.
Here's the deal: Apparently, soft cheese, hot dogs, and lunch meat are all teeming with deadly bacteria, and if you so much as think about a sub sandwich, your embryo/fetus/baby/self will totally die, and it will be all your fault! Be afraid! Be very, very afraid! Quick! Start obsessing about every morsel that you eat! That cheese you ate last night--was it soft, or semi-soft? If you melt hard cheddar, does it become soft cheese? What if you just chew it really well? What about grilled cheese sandwiches?
Okay, forget cheese. No more cheese at all! Or lunch meat! Or anything from a deli! Or precooked fish! Or prepared salads! Actually, just to be on the safe side, you shouldn't eat anything if you didn't personally watch it being prepared, because you can't be assured that it was handled in a sterile and sanitary manner!
Okay. Let's look at the numbers.
- There are 300,000,000 people in the United States.
- Approximately 4,000,000 babies are born in the United States each year, and (acknowledging stillbirths and multiple births) let's just assume that approximately 4,000,000 women are pregnant in a given year. I realize that this is kind of cheating, but my Googlin' fingers are tired, and hey, with numbers this big, I'm willing to settle for 'close enough'.
- Each year, around 2,500 people contract Listeriosis and 500 people die.
- Apparently, since pregnant women are more susceptible to Listeriosis due to freaky digestive changes, one in three cases involves a pregnant woman, so let's say that roughly 833 pregnant women get it and 167 die.
That sounds bad, right?
Well, by contrast, there are around 280 maternal deaths per year due to complications related to childbirth, and yet nowhere in these helpful handouts does it recommend that pregnant women avoid giving birth. While I'm on the subject, does anyone else find it kind of disturbing that there has been no significant improvement in maternal mortality rates in the United States in the last twenty years? All this expensive technology pushing up healthcare premiums, all these machines with blinky lights and dials, all these brightly colored handouts on avoiding the evils of deli meat, and we're still in the exact same boat as we were twenty years ago?
Roughly 280,000 low birth weight babies are born every year, and the March of Dimes lists poor maternal nutrition as one of the bajillion risk factors. Is it medically sound to tell pregnant women not to eat cold meats or prepared salads when inadequate nutrition is a more realistic concern than contamination? If a pregnant woman goes to McDonald's with five dollars to spend, do we really want her choosing the fries over the side salad every single time because she's so afraid of Listeria? Is a meatball sub a better nutritional choice than a chef's salad?
It's also worth pointing out that 42,000 people die in car accidents in the United States every year, and yet pregnancy websites are perfectly happy to tell you that car travel is totally safe, as long as you wear your seatbelt properly and take regular pee breaks.
What's my point?
Am I saying that we should all stay in the house to avoid car accidents? God, no. Household accidents finish off another 18,000 people a year, so you're kind of screwed either way. Am I saying that pregnant women should all live on nothing but brie and raw hot dog juice? No. Am I saying that I'd be happier not knowing about preventable hazards? Hell, no.
What I am saying is that I would like to be treated as an adult. I would like to be educated, not frightened. I would like to be advised about legitimate hazards, not patronized and talked down to. I would like to know about the real risks involved so that I can make informed decisions.
Also, I would really like a beer. My first craving, and it's beer? Who thought this up?